May 26, 2021 Planning Commission

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: THANK YOU, LEILA.

AND AT THIS TIME WE'LL GO AHEAD IF COMMISSIONER FRANZ CAN LEAD US IN THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: PLEASE PLACE YOUR HANDS OVER YOUR HEART.

I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS, ONE NATION UNDER GOD, INDIVISIBLE, WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: THANK YOU, COMMISSIONER FRANZ.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: ANY TIME.

[4. STATEMENT FROM THE COMMISSION SECRETARY]

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: IF WE CAN GET A STATEMENT FROM OUR COMMISSION SECRETARY.

THE GENERAL RULES OF COURTESY FOR VIRTUAL MEETINGS ARE FOLLOWS.

PLEASE BE MINDFUL OF BACKGROUND NOISE WHEN JOINING THE VIRTUAL MEETING.

PARTICIPANTS MUST MUTE THEIR MICROPHONE WHEN THEY ARE NOT SPEAKING.

WHEN YOUR MICROPHONE IS NOT MUTED, AVOID ACTIVITY THAT COULD CREATE ADDITIONAL NOISE.

POSITION YOUR CAMERA PROPERLY.

IF YOU CHOOSE HAD TO USE A WEB CAMERA BE SURE IT IS IN A STABLE POSITION AND FOCUSED AT EYE LEVEL IF POSSIBLE IF YOU WILL BE SHARING CONTENT DURING THE

[5. STATEMENT FROM THE CITY ATTORNEY]

MEETING, MAKE SURE YOU HAVE THE FILE AND/OR LINKS READY TO GO BEFORE THE MEETING BEGINS.

MEMBERS FROM THE PUBLIC WISHING TO PROVIDE ORAL TESTIMONY MUST FOLLOW THE INSTRUCTIONS ON THE AGENDA AND/OR ONLINE IN ORDER TO PROVIDE PUBLIC COMMENTS FOR.

AGENDA OR BE NON-AGENDA ITEMS. MEMBERS FROM THE PUBLIC WISHING TO PROVIDE ORAL TESTIMONY HAVE THREE MINUTES TO PROVIDE ORAL TESTIMONY.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: THANK YOU, EVELYN.

IF WE CAN GET A STATEMENT FROM OUR CITY ATTORNEY.

>> ZACH HEINSELMAN: THERE ARE NO DIRECTIVES ISSUED TEMPORARILY HALTING LOCAL GOVERNMENT PROCESSING LAND USE AND DEVELOPMENT OF APPLICATIONS AND/OR CONSIDERATION OF POLICY ACTIONS INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENTS, ZONING CODE AMENDMENTS AND KNEW OR AMENDED SPECIFIC PLANS THEREFORE THE CITY OF INDIO CONTINUES TO PROCESS APPLICATIONS IN ACCORDANCE WITH STATE AND LOCAL REQUIREMENTS.

THE CITY OF INDIO IS FOLLOWING GOVERNOR NEWSOM'S EXECUTIVE ORDINANCE N-25-20 AND N-29-20.

PERTAINING TO THE BROWN ACT THESE EXECUTIVE ORDERS ALLOW GOVERNMENTAL ENTITIES TO CONDUCT MEETINGS BY ELECTRONIC MEANS AND FOR MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC TO OBSERVE THE MEETING ELECTRONICALLY AS WELL AS PROVIDE PUBLIC COMMENT OR PUBLIC TESTIMONY TELEPHONICALLY OR OTHERWISE ELECTRONICALLY.

ACCORDINGLY, THE CITY COUNCIL AND PLANNING COMMISSION ARE CURRENTLY CONDUCTING SCHEDULED MEETINGS IN A VIRTUAL MEETING FORMAT.

THE CITY OF INDIO HAS IMPLEMENTED TECHNOLOGY SOLUTIONS THAT ALLOW MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC.

TO OBSERVE AND OFFER PUBLIC COMMENT AS WELL AS PUBLIC TESTIMONY DURING PUBLIC HEARINGS AT SCHEDULED PLANNING COMMISSION MEETINGS.

THE CITY IS COMMITTED TO PROVIDING PUBLIC PARTICIPATION OPPORTUNITIES WHILE ALSO COMPLYING WITH THE REQUIREMENTS FOR PROCESSING OF LAND USE AND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW APPLICATIONS AND/OR CONSIDERATION OF POLICY ACTIONS.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: THANK YOU, ZACH.

NOW WE MOVE TO ITEM 7, THE MINUTES FOR MAY 12, 2021.

>> ZACH HEINSELMAN: CHAIR, IF I MAY, I THINK WE MISSED ITEM 6.

[00:05:02]

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: EVELYN, DO WE HAVE ANY PUBLIC COMMENTS?

>> EVELYN BELTRAN: WE DO NOT.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: SO WE HAVE NO COMMENTS.

WE MOVE ON TO ITEM 7 WHICH ARE THIS MINUTES.

[7. MINUTES]

IF THE COMMISSION HAS A CHANCE TO REVIEW THE MINUTES AND, IF SO, IF I CAN THERE'S A MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES DATED MAY 12, 2021.

>> MADAME CHAIR, I'LL MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES FROM MAY 12, 2021 MEETING.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: SECOND.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: AND IF WE CAN PLEASE GET ROLL CALL.

NEXT WE HAVE OUR PUBLIC HEARING ITEM, WHICH IS THEY FIESTA KIA ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 20-11-553 CONDITIONAL USE PERMITS AND DESIGN REVIEW.

[8.1 Fiesta Kia – Environmental Assessment 20-11-553, Conditional Use Permit 20-11-1065 & Design Review 20-11-481]

OKAY.

AND I BELIEVE, NIKKI, YOU WILL BE PRESENTING ON THIS ITEM?

>> NIKKI GOMEZ: THANK YOU, MA'AM CHAIR.

LET ME GO AHEAD AND SHARE MY SCREEN.

CAN YOU SEE MY SCREEN?

>> IT IS NOT IN PRESENTATION VIEW.

>> NIKKI GOMEZ: LET ME TRY ONE MORE TIME.

HOW ABOUT NOW?

>> ZACH HEINSELMAN: CHAIR, IF I COULD CORRECT ONE THING FOR THE RECORDS IF WE COULD GO OVER AND REVISIT THE MINUTES.

I WAS REMISS IN NOTING THAT IT LOOKS LIKE OUR NEW COMMISSIONER VALDEZ WASN'T PRESENT DURING MAY 12TH.

SHE WAS NOT A COMMISSIONER AT THAT TIME.

SO I WAS WONDERING, CHAIR, IF YOU MIGHT SUGGEST RETURNING TO CONSIDER THOSE MINUTES AND COMMISSIONER VALDEZ, SUGGESTING THAT YOU MIGHT ABSTAIN FROM THAT VOTE, GIVEN THAT YOU WEREN'T PRESENT AT THE MEETING.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: SO WE'LL GO AHEAD AND CALL AGAIN FOR THE APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES FOR MAY 21ST.

SO WE JUST HAVE TO CALL INTO A MOTION AGAIN, CORRECT, IS THAT HOW IT GOES?

>> ZACH HEINSELMAN: THAT WOULD BE CORRECT.

RODRIGUEZ CEJA: I WILL MAKE THE MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF MAY 12, 2021 PLANNING COMMISSION.

SO -- >> COMM.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: I'LL SECOND.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: IF WE CAN GET ROLL CALL, PLEASE.

>> AND COMMISSIONER VALDEZ.

>> ABSTAIN.

>> EVELYN BELTRAN: THANK YOU.

MOTION CARRIES 3-0.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: WE'RE WAITING FOR NIKKI TO COME UP.

I KNOW I'M SUPPOSED TO KIND OF WAIT UNTIL THE END, BUT I JUST WANT TO ALSO WELCOME COMMISSIONER VALDEZ TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION.

>> COMMISSIONER VALDEZ: THANK YOU.

>> NIKKI GOMEZ: MADAME CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION, I HOPE YOU SEE MY SCREEN NOW.

SORRY ABOUT THAT.

>> COMM.

RODRIGUEZ CEJA: YES.

>> NIKKI GOMEZ: SO TONIGHT FIESTA KIA PROJECT, ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 20-11-553, CUP 20-11-1065 AND DESIGN REVIEW 20-11-481.

[00:10:06]

SO THE PROJECT SITE IS LOCATED AT THE WEST CORNER OF VARNER ROAD AND FIFTIES WAY AND I'M SURE MOST OF YOU ARE FAMILIAR THAT THIS WILL BE ALONG THAT AUTO MALL CENTER RIGHT ON VARNER ROAD AREA.

AND IT'S RIGHT NEXT TO THE AUTO, TOYOTA USED SALES CAR DEALERSHIP.

IT'S GOING TO ENCOMPASS -- IT'S GOING TO BE WITHIN A 3.5 ACRES LOT, AND IT IS -- BE THE ZONING DESIGNATION FOR THIS SITE IS BUSINESS PARK WITH A REGIONAL COMMERCIAL DESIGNATION FROM THE GENERAL PLAN.

AND I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO HIGHLIGHT THAT THIS WOULD BE THE EDGE OVER CITY.

THIS IS OUR BOUNDARY LINE.

SO WE ARE BORDERING AT THREE OF OUR SIDES, WHICH UNDER THE RIVERSIDE COUNTY JURISDICTION.

TO THE NORTH OF THIS PROPERTY IS THE SUN CITY/PALM DESERT COMMUNITY, AND RIGHT BELOW THE WEST AREA IS THE COMMUNITY SHOPPING CENTER, WHICH MOST OF YOU ARE ALSO FAMILIAR WITH.

SO THE SITE PLAN SHOWS THE CAR DEALERSHIP, FIESTA KIA CENTRALLY LOCATED AT THE SITE.

THIS IS GOING TO BE A 25,000 SQUARE FOOT FACILITY WITH AN ASSOCIATED EMPLOYEE PARKING, AUTO DISPLAY, AS WELL AS CUSTOMER PARKING.

IT WILL ALSO HAVE ITS SERVICE AREA FOR REPAIRS AND SUCH THAT WILL BE HOUSED HERE IN THE REAR PORTION OF THE BUILDING, AND ITS ASSOCIATED CAR WASH ONLY FOR THE DEALERSHIP PURPOSES AND NOT OPEN TO THE PUBLIC, AS WELL AS THEIR ASSOCIATED LANDSCAPING AS WELL AS CAR DISPLAY FOR SALES PURPOSES.

THE ACCESS WILL BE FRONTING -- THE MAIN ACCESS WILL BE FRONTING ALONG VARNER ROAD AND THERE WILL ALSO BE ACCESS LOOK FIFTIES WAY.

FOR THE FLOOR PLAN OF THE BUILDING, FRONTING VARNER ROAD WOULD BE THE SERVICE.

RECEPTION AND SERVICE AREA WILL BE RIGHT AT THE WEST PORTION OF THE BUILDING THAT WILL THEN GO INTO THE SERVICE GARAGE FOR REPAIRS IN THE CAR WASH PORTION.

IT WILL INCLUDE CONSULTATION OFFICES AS WELL AS SALES OFFICES, A LOUNGE AREA WAITING FOR THE SERVICE PORTION OF THE USE, AS WELL AS PARTS AND DELIVERY AREA.

AND THEN THERE WILL BE A SECOND FLOOR.

THE SECOND FLOOR IS A LIMITED SIZE THAT WILL ONLY HOUSE ADMINISTRATION PURPOSES AS WELL AS CONFERENCE ROOM AND GREAT ROOM AS WELL AS JUST A BATHROOM, AND THERE WILL ALSO BE A MEZZANINE RIGHT THERE.

SO IT WOULDN'T ENCOMPASS THE ENTIRE FIRST FLOOR OF THE BUILDING.

FOR THE ELEVATIONS, AND I'LL JUST KIND OF WALK YOU THROUGH THIS COLOR COORDINATED AND WE'LL START FROM VARNER -- OR YOU CAN START FROM VARNER AVENUE, WHICH IS THE BLUE PORTION, AND THIS IS REALLY WHERE THE FRONTAGE OF THE BUILDING

[00:35:30]

WILL BE, RIGHT AS THE MAIN AREA THERE AT VARNER ROAD AND IT WILL BE THE SIGNAGE GLASS, AND YOU CAN SEE THAT THE DIFFERENT BUILDING MATERIALS HERE THAT WE WILL KIND OF GO INTO WHEN THE RENDERINGS COME IN IN THE LATER SLIDE.

THE REAR PORTION, THE BACK END AREA WILL BE THE SERVICE AREA AND WILL HAVE THESE GARAGE DOORS.

AND IT WILL MOSTLY BE BLOCKS, CMU MATERIAL.

TO THE EAST PORTION, AND THIS WOULD BE ALONG THE FIFTIES WAY, AND IT WILL MOSTLY, YOU KNOW, STILL BE AT THE SERVICE AREA HERE IN THE BACK, AND THE DELIVERY PICKUP AREA WILL BE RIGHT ON THIS PORTION AS WELL.

AND THERE WILL BE -- THE DESIGN WILL KIND OF WRAP AROUND WITH THE GLASS AND THE METAL, THE METAL PIECES THAT WILL KIND OF CHANGE UP THE MATERIAL AND THE COLOR OF THE BUILDING AS YOU CAN SEE LATER ON.

AND THEN ON THE WEST PORTION, WHICH IS GOING TO BE -- GOING TO BE VACANT LOT FOR NOW, AND THAT WILL BE -- THIS IS GOING TO BE WHERE YOU'RE GOING TO BE PULLING UP TO SERVICE YOUR CAR TO KIND OF CHECK YOU IN.

AND THEN THIS WILL BE THE SERVICE AREA BACK HERE FOR REPAIRS.

AND SO JUST TO KIND OF SHOW YOU THE RENDERING OF THIS FACILITY OR THIS BUILDING, SO WE CAN JUST COLOR COORDINATED HERE FROM VARNER ROAD, AS YOU ARE SEEING IT FROM THE FRONT, THIS WOULD BE WHAT YOU WILL SEE AS YOU DRIVE UP OR PASS BY THERE.

AND IT WILL BE THE GLASS AS WELL AS A METAL PANELS AND THEY WILL BE WHITE METAL PANELS.

IT A MODERN STYLE BUILDING.

AND THEN THAT COLOR CHANGE WILL THEN BE CONTRASTED WITH THE GRAY COOL TONE, MASONRY WALLS, AND AWNINGS WILL OBVIOUSLY COVER MOST OF THE GLASS PORTION OF THE BUILDING.

SO THIS IS KIND OF MOSTLY WHAT YOU SEE AT THE FRONTAGE, AND THIS WOULD BE ON THE SIDE, WHICH IS ON FIFTIES WAY.

AND THEN YOU CAN SEE THERE DEFINITELY THE DIFFERENTIATION OF THE BUILDING AS WELL AS THE BACK CORNER HERE, AND HERE IS THE CAR WASH WAS AB MENTIONED BEFORE, ALSO WILL BE BACK THERE.

THE BACK OF HOUSE, THE REAR BACK OF THE BUILDING AND THE CAR WASH RIGHT HERE, ACCESS TO THE SERVICE AREA, AND THEN A VIEW FROM THE VACANT LOT TO THE WEST SIDE OF THE PROPERTY HERE.

AND THIS IS THE PROPOSED LANDSCAPE PLAN SUBMITTED.

AND SO IT WILL DEFINITELY INCORPORATE DESERT, DROUGHT TOLERANT LANDSCAPE PALETTE THROUGHOUT THE PERIMETER OF THE SITE.

AND, OF COURSE, THE PALMS WILL BE INCLUDED AS PART OF THAT.

AND EVEN IN THE INTERIOR PORTION OF THE PROJECT SITE, THEY WILL ALSO INCORPORATE THAT, ESPECIALLY IN THE DISPLAY AREAS.

AND SO THE RECOMMENDATION FOR YOU TONIGHT IS TO ADOPT RESOLUTION 1944 FOR THE ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT MITIGATED NEGATIVE DECLARATION AND MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM FOR THE ENTIRE SITE, AND THE FIESTA KIA DEALERSHIP WOULD BE PHASE I OF THIS ENTIRE PROJECT.

ALSO TO ADOPT RESOLUTION NUMBER 1995 FOR THE CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT TO ALLOW NEW CAR DEALERSHIP USE IN THE BUSINESS PARK ZONE DISTRICT.

AND THEN RESOLUTION NUMBER 1996 TO APPROVE DESIGN REVIEW 20-11-481 FOR THE SITE DESIGN INCLUDING THE SITE CIRCULATION, PARKING, BUILD ARCHITECTURE AND LANDSCAPING FOR THE NEW CAR DEALERSHIP FIESTA KIA.

THE OWNER IS HERE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS AS WELL AS MYSELF, STAFF, WILL BE HERE TO ANSWER ANY OF YOUR QUESTIONS.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: THANK YOU, NIKKI.

I WANT TO GO AHEAD AND OPEN THIS PUBLIC HEARING ITEM, AND IF ANY OF THE COMMISSIONERS HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR NIKKI.

>> CHAIRPERSON FRANZ: I HAVE A QUESTION, NIKKI.

>> NIKKI GOMEZ: SURE.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: WE DIDN'T TOUCH ON PHASE II ANYWHERE EXCEPT FOR IN THE, BASICALLY THE REQUEST TO APPROVE.

SO ON THE RESOLUTION THE ONLY REAL PLACE THAT WE ADDRESSED PHASE II.

SO WHAT ARE WE PROVING FOR PHASE II? JUST THE ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT?

>> NIKKI GOMEZ: SINCE THIS IS REVIEWED, BOTH PHASE I AND PHASE II IS REVIEWED FOR THE ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT SO THAT WE COMPLY WITH CEQA.

THE PHASE II WILL APPEAR BEFORE YOU ON A SEPARATE ENTITLEMENT.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: SO THERE WILL BE A WHOLE DESIGN REVIEW, ET CETERA, ET CETERA, THAT'LL COME SOMEWHERE DOWN THE ROAD.

>> NIKKI GOMEZ: THAT'S CORRECT.

ALTHOUGH THEY HAVE PROPOSED AS PART OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT THAT THERE WILL BE A DRIVE-THROUGH RETAIL PROPOSAL NOR THAT, BUT THAT WILL COME BEFORE YOU IN A SEPARATE DESIGN REVIEW ENTITLEMENT ALTOGETHER.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: OKAY.

HAS THE DEVELOPER -- DO THEY HAVE A TIMELINE FOR THAT? IS THAT COMING, DO THEY THINK SOON? OR IS IT JUST SOMETHING NECESSITY WANT TO DO FARTHER OUT IN THE FUTURE?

>> NIKKI GOMEZ: SO FOR THIS PARTICULAR ENTITLEMENT IT WOULD BE STRICTLILY FOR KIA SO IT MIGHT BE THAT IT WOULD BE A SEPARATE DEVELOPER THAT MIGHT COME AND AND THEN THEY WILL PURSUE THAT, YES.

>> LEILA NAMVAR: MADAME CHAIR, IF I MAY, WOULD I LIKE TO ADD ONE SMALL POINT.

[00:20:04]

SO COMMISSIONER FRANZ THEY DID THE ENVIRONMENTAL A AS WHOLE SKO THEY DIDN'T DO PIECEMEAL BECAUSE UNDER THE CEQA, AS YOU KNOW, IF THERE'S A PROJECT COMING, WE CAN'T JUST ANALYZE THE KIA AND NOT ANALYZE THE REST.

SO TO BE CONSISTENT WITH CEQA, THEY ANALYZED THE ENTIRE PROPERTY PHASE I AND PHRASE II.

HOWEVER, IT WAS BEFORE YOU AS NIKKI SAID IS ONLY PHASE I.

PHASE II WILL COME BEFORE YOU AT A LATER DATE, AND I DON'T -- WE DON'T KNOW WHEN.

THE APPLICANT CAN TELL US IF IT IS AN SOON OR IT IS LATE.

ANY EVENT WHEN THEY COME BACK, WE WILL ANALYZE BASED ON THE CEQA AND WE WILL BRING IT BACK BEFORE THE PLANNING COMMISSION WITH PROPER ENTITLEMENT.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: PERFECT.

THANK YOU, LEILA.

I WAS PRETTY SURE THAT'S WHAT IT WAS ALL SAYING BUT YOU WANTED TO CLARIFY BECAUSE IT SEEMED WE DIDN'T TOUCH ON IT SO I JUST WANTED IT FOR THE RECORD.

SO THANK YOU.

>> ZACH HEINSELMAN: CHAIR, IF I MAY TAKE A MOMENT TO CONFIRM WITH MS. GOMEZ, I BELIEVE A MEMO REGARDING RESOLUTION 1996 AND A CLARIFICATION OF ONE OF THE CONDITIONS, I BELIEVE IT WAS F-12 WAS DISTRIBUTED TO THE COMMISSION AND POSTED ONLINE PUBLICALLY AVAILABLE AS WELL AS PART OF THE RECORD.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: YES, I WAS GOING TO GET TO IF THERE WAS ANY OTHER PUBLIC COMMENTS, CORRECT, OR ANY OTHER ADDITIONAL ITEMS. ANY ADDITIONAL COMMENTS TO STAFF? DO YOU HAVE QUESTIONS OF THE APPLICANT? SINCE THERE ARE NONE, WE'LL GO AHEAD, IF THE APPLICANT IS PRESENT, IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO ADD ANYTHING TO THE REPORT.

>> SPEAKER: SO, HI.

I'M MICHAEL ROBINSON.

I'M WORKING WITH ROBINSON HILL FOR -- AS A CONSULTANT TO THE OWNER.

THE ONLY THING I WOULD ADD GENERALLY TO THE REPORT WAS THAT, AND THE SITE PLAN DID SHOW A 150-FOOT SETBACK REQUIREMENT FROM ANY NEIGHBORHOOD PROPERTY WAS ON THE SITE PLAN BUT NOT REALLY CLARIFIED.

SO WE ARE ACCOMMODATING THAT.

THERE'S ALSO A 35-FOOT HEIGHT LIMITATION, AND WE ARE 26 FEET.

SO WE'RE NOT ASKING FOR ANY, ANYTHING UNIQUE OR ANY VARIANCES TO THE ZONING CODE AT ALL.

THAT'S ALL I HAVE RIGHT AT THE MOMENT.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: ANY OTHER COMMISSIONERS HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE APPLICANT?

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: I GUESS I DO HAVE ONE QUESTION.

IS THIS KIA DEALERSHIP A NEW DEALERSHIP COMING INTO THE COACHELLA VALLEY OR IS IT MOVING ONE OF THE OTHER KIA DEALERSHIPS?

>> SPEAKER: THIS ONE'S BRAND NEW.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: BRAND NEW.

>> YEAH.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: THAT WAS MORE CURIOSITY.

>> IT'S THE LATEST KIA PROTOTYPE, SO -- AND IT'S A BRAND NEW DEALERSHIP.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: PERFECT.

SO IT'S A NEW ADDITION TO THE COACHELLA VALLEY.

THAT'S GOOD TO KNOW.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: THANK YOU, COMMISSIONER FRANZ.

ANY OTHER QUESTIONS FOR THE APPLICANTS?

>> VICE CHAIRPERSON YSIANO: NONE FOR ME.

>> LOPEZ: THE OWNER OF THE KIA, DOES HE HAVE ANY OTHER KIAS IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA OR IS THIS THE FIRST ONE OPENING UP?

>> SPEAKER: THE OWNER IS THE SAME OWNER THAT HAS THE FORD, THE FIESTA FORD DOWN THE STREET.

HE ALSO HAS A PROJECT IN PALM SPRINGS, PALM SPRINGS MOTORS, I THINK THAT'S ACTUALLY CATHEDRAL CITY.

THIS IS THE FIRST KIA DEALERSHIP THAT HE WILL HAVE.

>> OKAY.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: THANK YOU, COMMISSIONER.

I HAVE ONE QUESTION IN REGARDS TO JOBS.

WHAT IS THE PROJECTED JOBS FROM THIS DEALERSHIP THAT WILL BE COMING INTO THE CITY? DO YOU KNOW APPROXIMATELY HOW MANY YOU MAY BE HIRING FOR THIS NEW DEALERSHIP?

>> SPEAKER: YOU'RE ASKING ME.

I'M NOT SURE WHAT IT'S GOING TO TAKE.

I THINK THERE'S -- I THINK HE'S TELLING ME THERE'S -- THERE COULD BE AS MANY AS 100 EMPLOYEES THAT ARE ON-SITE AT ONE PARTICULAR TIME, SO I WOULD ASSUME IT'S MORE THAN THAT.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: AND THESE ARE MOST LIKELY GOING TO BE NEW EMPLOYEES?

>> SPEAKER: THEY WOULD BE NEW EMPLOYEES, YEAH, MM-HM.

[00:25:06]

YES.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: IF THERE ARE NO OTHER FURTHER QUESTIONS, I'M GOING TO GO AHEAD AND ASK EVELYN IF THERE'S ANY OTHER PUBLIC COMMENTS ON THE ITEM.

>> EVELYN BELTRAN: THERE ARE NONE.

WELL, I GUESS WE'LL GO AHEAD AND CLOSE PUBLIC COMMENTS, AND CLOSE THE HEARING, AND AT THIS TIME WE'LL JUST GO AHEAD AND GO AROUND WITH EACH COMMISSIONER.

LET'S START WITH COMMISSIONER FRANZ.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: CAN I ASK A COUPLE OF QUESTIONS OF STAFF JUST BECAUSE I THINK I'M KIND OF MISSING ERIC.

SO CAN WE GO BACK TO THE SITE PLAN?

>> NIKKI GOMEZ: SURE.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: I'M PRETTY SURE THE ANSWERS ARE SIMPLE BUT I WANT TO MAKE SURE I'M NOT MISSING SOMETHING.

SO WHERE IS MOST OF THE EQUIPMENT BEING PLACED, AIR CONDITIONERS, THE THINGS THAT, YOU KNOW, WE USUALLY CAN TELL WHERE THERE'S A HIGHER WALL OR WHERE THEY'RE KIND OF BEING HIDDEN.

WHERE -- I DIDN'T QUITE FIGURE OUT WHERE THAT IS ALL BEING PLACED HERE.

>> SPEAKER: CAN I ANSWER THAT?

>> NIKKI GOMEZ: PLEASE.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: CAN WE REOPEN THE PUBLIC COMMENT? SORRY.

JACKIE?

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: WE'LL GO AHEAD AND OPEN PUBLIC COMMENTS.

>> SPEAKER: ALL RIGHT.

SO YOU CAN SEE FROM THE SITE PLAN THE BUILDING IS DIVIDED INTO TWO SECTIONS.

THE ONE IN THE BACK IS THE SERVICE BAY, AND THE ONE IN THE FRONT IS FOR THE SALES AND SERVICE.

SO YOU THE EQUIPMENT THAT'S THE MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT THAT'S ON THE ROOFTOP WOULD GO CLOSER TO VARNER ON THE SALES AND SERVICE SIDE.

SO -- AND THIS WILL BE THE BACK OF THE BUILDING.

IT WILL STILL BE ON THE FRONT BUILDINGS, THE FRONT PORTION, AND THERE WOULD BE A ROOF SCREEN.

THAT PROBABLY WON'T BE VISIBLE.

IT WASN'T VISIBLE IN ANY OF OUR 3D PHOTO MONTAGES BUT THERE WILL BE A ROOF SCREEN THAT SCREENS THE UNITS IN THAT AREA.

SO IT'S CLOSER TO VARNER THAN THE RESIDENTIAL COMMUNITY.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: SO JUST TO BE CLEAR, THE SCREENS WILL MAKE SURE THEY GO ALL THE WAY AROUND AND ENCOMPASS THE BUILDING SO THAT YOU CAN'T REALLY CAN'T SEE ANY OF THAT EQUIPMENT, CORRECT?

>> SPEAKER: CORRECT.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: THE OTHER QUESTION I HAD IS I DID NOTE ONE OF THE PUBLIC COMMENTS YOU RECEIVED ASKED ABOUT LIGHTING, AND ENSURING THAT ALL THE LIGHTING WOULD BE SHIELDED TO FACE DOWN AND NOT UP AND NONE OF THE LIGHTS WILL, YOU KNOW, LEAVE THE AREA SINCE YOU DO HAVE NEIGHBORS IN THE BACK.

I'M ASSUMING THAT'S ALSO NOT SOMETHING WE HAVE TO DISCUSS, THAT THAT'S THE WAY IT IS.

>> SPEAKER: GO AHEAD.

>> NIKKI GOMEZ: YES.

SO I'VE ALREADY REVIEWED THE PHOTO METRIC PLAN FOR THE SITE, AND SO THERE IS ABSOLUTELY NO LIGHTING SPILLAGE THAT WILL GO BEYOND THE -- THIS PROPERTY HERE AND ALL THE LIGHTING.

YOU SEE THESE POSTS RIGHT HERE.

THAT'S AT LEAST 60 FEET AWAY FROM THE SOUTH PROPERTY.

AND THEY HAVE BEEN VERY CONSERVATIVE ALSO WITH THEIR HEIGHT OF THOSE POLES SO THAT THEY ARE DIRECTED DOWNWARDS OR DIRECTED TOWARDS THE BUILDING.

AND SOME OF THESE WALL MOUNTINGS WILL OBVIOUSLY BE SHIELDED DOWN TOWARDS THE PAVEMENT.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: THE GROUND.

>> NIKKI GOMEZ: EXACTLY.

SO THERE WILL BE, AS SHOWN ON THE PHOTO METRIC, THERE WILL BE NO SPILLAGE THAT WILL OCCUR AT THAT NORTH PORTION.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: GREAT.

SO A COUPLE MORE THINGS.

EVERY TIME WE HAVE A DEALERSHIP, WE HAVE THE SAME SIMILAR CONVERSATIONS AND CONCERNS.

IT'S NOT NEW.

IT'S JUST WE NEED TO MAKE SURE WE DISCUSS IT.

I FORGET TO THE DEALERSHIP THAT HAS COME INTO NOT TOO LONG AGO.

THE CONVERSATION WAS ABOUT DELIVERY HOURS, YOU KNOW, UNLOADING AND LOADING THOSE VEHICLES.

IT MAKES A LOT OF NOISE.

AND IT'S A DEALERSHIP.

WE KNOW THAT.

IS THERE A SET SCHEDULE OR AN HOUR OR LIMITATION OF HOURS WHEN THOSE DELIVERIES CAN TAKE PLACE?

>> NIKKI GOMEZ: THE APPLICANT CAN ADD TO IT, BUT ACCORDING TO THEM, THERE WILL ONLY BE ONE TRANSPORT PER DAY.

MICHAEL, IF YOU COULD CONFIRM THAT, THAT WOULD BE -- >> SPEAKER: I THINK FOR THE TRANSPORTS, I THINK THAT WAS ON THE LIST I GAVE YOU.

I THINK THAT WAS THE MAXIMUM ONE PER DAY, YEAH.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: IS THERE GOING TO BE LIKE CERTAIN HOURS ONLY SO

THEY'RE NOT COMING IN SUPER EARLY OR SUPER LATE OR -- >> SPEAKER: YEAH, I'M NOT -- I'M NOT CERTAIN ABOUT THE ACTUAL SCHEDULE.

I'D HAVE TO CHECK WITH THE OWNERSHIP.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: NIKKI, DO YOU REMEMBER THAT LAST DEALERSHIP THAT WE DID

[00:30:02]

BEFORE? I CAN'T REMEMBER WHICH ONE IT WAS.

WAS IT DODGE? I I CAN'T REMEMBER.

WE HAD SPECIFIC HOURS WHERE THE DELIVERY CAN ONLY BE MADE DURING THESE HOURS.

I COULD NOT COME LATER OR EARLIER.

DO YOU REMEMBER THAT?

>> NIKKI GOMEZ: I DON'T REMEMBER, BUT I AM HOPING THAT LEILA WOULD.

I DON'T BELIEVE I WAS IN HERE YET.

>> LEILA NAMVAR: I NEED TO DO A BACK CHECK, BUT I DON'T THINK WE LIMITED THEM TO SPECIFIC HOURS.

IT WAS JUST THEM TELLING US WHAT HOURS THEY NORMALLY USE.

BUT IN THIS SPECIFIC PROJECT AND ANY OTHER PROJECT, THEY STILL NEED TO DO HERE TO THE NOISE, CITY'S NOISE ORDINANCE, SO WE HAVE A CONDITION ON SOUND AM AMPLIFY CASES AND THINGS LIKE THAT, AND THEY NEED TO ADHERE TO THE NOISE ORDINANCE OF THE CITY.

THE ONE THING THAT THIS DEALERSHIP IS NOT DOING WHICH OTHER DEALERSHIPS HAVE IS THEY DON'T HAVE A PA SYSTEM, SO THAT NOISE THAT ALWAYS EVERYBODY IS COMPLAINING ABOUT NOT HERE.

BUT IF YOU GIVE ME FIVE, TEN MINUTES, I MAY BE ABLE TO PULL UP THAT DODGE DEALERSHIP TO SEE IF THERE I WAS CONDITION.

I DOUBT WE ADDED THE CONDITION BECAUSE OUR ZONING ORDINANCE -- I MEAN, OUR NOISE ORDINANCE JUST TALKS ABOUT DECIBELS AND ALSO TALKS ABOUT SOME HOURS, SO BEFORE 6:00 THEY CAN COME HERE AND, YOU KNOW, THERE'S HOURS THERE WHICH EVERYBODY NEEDS TO ADHERE TO THAT.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: COULD WE HAVE A LITTLE MORE CLARITY ON IS THAT? THIS DEALERSHIP IS CLOSER TO THOSE HOTELS THAN A LOT OF THE -- HOMES THAN A LOT OF THE OTHERS HAD BEEN SO THAT COULD QUICKLY BECOME A PROBLEM WHICH HOPEFULLY IT WILL NOT.

>> KEVIN SNYDER: THE PLANNING COMMISSION HAS THE DISCRETION TO ESTABLISH HOURS OF OPERATION AS IT RELATES TO THE PARTICULAR CONCERN THAT THE COMMISSIONER RAISED.

SO, FOR EXAMPLE, IF THE COMMISSION WANTED TO ESTABLISH TRANSPORT UNLOADING HOURS FROM -- AND I'M JUST MAKING THIS UP -- BUT 8:00 A.M.

TO 8:00 P.M., AS AN EXAMPLE THAT THOSE COULD COME IN, YOU COULD DO THAT AS AN ADDED CONDITION TO THE CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT APPROVAL.

THAT'S WITHIN THE COMMISSION'S AUTHORITY IF YOU BELIEVE, AND AS COMMISSIONER FRANZ NOTED, THIS PARTICULAR SITE IS CLOSER TO RESIDENCES THAN THE OTHER DEALERSHIPS THAT ARE SEPARATED BY A PUBLIC STREET, SO IF THE COMMISSION AS A WHOLE FELT THAT I WAS CONCERN YOU WANTED TO ADDRESS WITH SOME ESTABLISHMENT OF HOURS UNLOADING, YOU THE DISCRETION TO DO THAT.

LEILA, IF YOU COULD GET INFORMATION ON THAT LAST ONE TO SEE IF WE DID WHAT I REMEMBER, THAT WOULD BE GREAT, AND WE'LL SEE HOW MY FELLOW COMMISSIONERS FEEL ABOUT MAYBE ADDING A CONDITION.

I'M REALLY CAREFUL OF THE QUALITY OF LIFE OUR NEIGHBORS AND RESIDENTS, SO THAT'S IMPORTANT TO ME.

>> VICE CHAIRPERSON YSIANO: COMMISSIONER FRANZ.

I WOULD AGREE BEING THAT THIS IS A BIT CLOSER TO THE SOUTH SIDE OF SOME OF THOSE DEL WEBB HOMES.

I KNOW THAT DEL WEBB DOES NOT ALLOW ANY COMMERCIAL VEHICLES ON THEIR SITE BEFORE 7:00 A.M., SO MAYBE IF WE ADHERE TO THAT GUIDELINE.

I'M NOT SURE HOW LATE THEY'RE ALLOWED, MAYBE 7:00 A.M.

TO 5:00 P.M.

FOR LIKE COMMERCIAL CONSTRUCTION VEHICLES OR THINGS OF THAT NATURE ARE NOT ALLOWED ON-SITE BEFORE 7:00 A.M.

I KNOW.

>> KEVIN SNYDER: AND I DO HAVE TO REMIND THE COMMISSION YOU YOU DID REOPEN THE PUBLIC SO ANY MEMBERS BETWEEN THE COMMISSIONERS SHOULD BE WITHHELD UNTIL THE PUBLIC HEARING IS CLOSED.

I'M SORRY FOR THE INTERRUPTIONS BUT IT'S A TECHNICALITY WE HAVE TO FOLLOW.

SORRY.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: I'M ALL DONE.

SHOULD WE TAKE A QUICK RECESS UNTIL WE OPPRESSIVE THOSE DOCUMENTS? OR, ZACH, SHOULD I MOVE ON TO SEE IF THERE'S ANY OTHER COMMENTS OR CALLS THAT WE RECEIVED ON THIS PROJECT?

>> ZACH HEINSELMAN: WELL, AS DIRECTOR SNYDER NOTED, THE HEARING IS OPEN.

IF THE APPLICANT DIDN'T HAVE ANY KIND OF RESPONSES TO THE QUESTIONS THAT THE COMMISSIONERS WERE JUST ASKING, YOU COULD CHECK TO SEE IF THERE WAS PUBLIC COMMENT.

IF THERE WERE NO PUBLIC COMMENT OR NO OTHER QUESTIONS FOR THE APPLICANT TEAM, YOU WOULD BE WITHIN YOUR DISCRETION TO CLOSE THE HEARING.

YOU CAN ASK STAFF FOLLOW-UP QUESTIONS ABOUT WHATEVER DOCUMENT MS. NAMVAR OR MORE INFORMATION SHE MAY BE ABLE TO PROVIDE AT THAT POINT.

I GUESS, EVELYN, IS THERE ANY OTHER PUBLIC COMMENTS?

[00:35:01]

>> EVELYN BELTRAN: STAFF DID NOT RECEIVE ANY FURTHER ORAL COMMENTS OR ANY PUBLIC COMMENTS FOR THIS ITEM, AND ANY ITEMS THAT ANY CORRESPONDENCE THAT WAS RECEIVED PRIOR TO THIS MEETING WAS ALSO DISTRIBUTED TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION AND MADE AVAILABLE ON THE WEBSITE AND AS PART OF THE RECORD FOR THIS PROJECT.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: THANK YOU, EVELYN.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: JACKIE, SINCE WE HAVE A MINUTE, CAN I ASK ONE MORE QUESTION? NIKKI IS GOING TO LOVE ME TODAY.

NIKKI, CAN YOU TALK TO ME A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE SIGNAGE, WHERE THE SIGNS ARE GOING TO BE PLACED AND HOW THEY'RE COMPARABLE TO THE OTHER DEALERSHIPS IN THE SURROUNDING AREA.

>> NIKKI GOMEZ: SO THE SIGNAGE FOR THIS PARTICULAR -- THEY HAVE NOT INCLUDED IT IN THE ENTITLEMENTS.

THIS IS OBVIOUSLY PROPOSED.

AND IT IS COULD BE THAT THAT'S WHAT THEY'RE GOING TO SUBMIT.

SO ALL IT IS IS WE'RE JUST -- IT'S GOING TO GO BACK TO OUR 150 SIGN ZONING CODE THAT THEY WILL HAVE TO ABIDE NOW.

SINCE THEY ARE CLOSER TO THE CORRIDOR, I KNOW THAT THE OTHER DEALERSHIPS HAVE HAD THOSE MONUMENT SIGNS THAT WE WILL JUST REFER TO THE ZONING AND WE'LL HAVE TO COMPLY WITH THE BP ZONE SIGNAGE REQUIREMENT.

>> KEVIN SNYDER: NIKKI, CAN I ASK TO CLARIFY ANY BELIEVE THERE'S A CONDITIONAL OF APPROVAL FOR A SIGNAGE PROGRAM TO BE SUBMITTED.

>> NIKKI GOMEZ: THERE IS NONE.

IT WILL JUST HAVE TO GO BACK TO THE ACTUAL BP SIGNING CODE.

THERE IS NO SIGN PROGRAM THAT'S SUBMITTED.

>> KEVIN SNYDER: THANK YOU.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: THANK YOU, COMMISSIONER FRANZ.

>> LEILA NAMVAR: CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ, I CHECKED QUICKLY AND I DON'T SEE ANY CONDITION WAS ADDED AS HOURS OF OPERATION OR HOURS OF DELIVERY TO THE OTHER PROJECT, BUT AS DIRECTOR SNYDER SAID, THAT DOESN'T PROHIBIT THE COMMISSION, IF THEY WISH TO ADD SOME TYPE OF HOURS OF OPERATION OR HOURS OF DELIVERY TO CLOSE PROXIMITY TO THE RESIDENTIAL IN THE NORTH.

SO I JUST WANT TO LET THE COMMISSION KNOW.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: THANK YOU, LEILA.

IF THERE ARE NO OTHER COMMENTS, I'LL GO AHEAD AND CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING.

AND THEN WE CAN DELIBERATE GOING BACK TO COMMISSIONER FRANZ.

I MEAN, OVERALL I THINK IT'S GREAT TO WELCOME A NEW KIA DEALERSHIP.

IT'S NEW JOBS, 100 NEW JOBS IS NOTHING TO NOT BE EXCITED ABOUT.

IT'S A NEW BUSINESS IN THE CITY.

OVERALL IT'S A WIN-WIN.

I LOVE THE MODERN ARCHITECTURE.

I LIKE THE WAY THEY LAID OUT THE SITE, THE COLORS.

I THINK IT'S GOING TO BE A BEAUTIFUL ADDITION TO THAT CORRIDOR, AND I HOPE THAT PHASE II DEVELOPS QUICKLY.

MY BIGGEST CONCERN IS THE DELIVERY, AND IF THE COMMISSIONERS AGREE, WOULD I LIKE TO SET HOURS AS A PARAMETER FOR DELIVERY SO THAT WE NEVER HAVE A DELIVERY SUPER EARLY IN THE MORNING OR SUPER LATE IN THE EVENING, AND I'M WILLING TO SEE WHAT OTHER OPINIONS THE COMMISSIONERS HAVE ON THAT POSSIBLE CONDITION.

OTHER THAN THAT I THINK IT'S GOING TO BE GREAT, AND I HOPE THAT THEY, YOU KNOW, DEVELOP PHASE II QUICKLY.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: THANK YOU, COMMISSIONER FRANZ.

COMMISSIONER VALDEZ.

>> COMMISSIONER VALDEZ: HELLO.

I, TOO, MANY REALLY EXCITED ABOUT THIS PROJECT.

I ACTUALLY DRIVE BY THIS AREA EVERY DAY, AND I WAS JUST THINKING THE OTHER DAY WE NEED TO HAVE A FAST FOOD PLACE SO I'M EXCITED TO SEE WHAT PHASE II LOOKS LIKE.

I ALSO LIKE THE MODERN ARCHITECTURE AND THE CLEANNESS OF EVERYTHING.

ONE THING IN THAT AREA THERE IS PEDESTRIANS THAT WALK TO THE STARBUCKS OR THE MCDONALD OR THE GROCERY STORE DOWN THE STREET, SO WITH INCREASED TRAFFIC ON THIS CORNER, YOU KNOW, IT WOULD BE SOMETHING JUST TO CONSIDER, YOU KNOW, THE PEDESTRIANS THAT GO THROUGH, THAT WALK THROUGH THERE TO GET TO THE MARKETPLACE, JUST MAKING IT IS SAFE FOR THEM TO CROSS WITH THE INCREASED TRAFFIC.

BUT BESIDES THAT I LOVE THE IDEA OF CREATING MORE JOBS AND OPPORTUNITY FOR OUR LOCALS.

SO THANK YOU.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: THANK YOU, COMMISSIONER VALDEZ.

VICE CHAIR.

>> VICE CHAIRPERSON YSIANO: YEAH, I THINK IT'S A GREAT PROJECT.

I LOOK FORWARD TO DEVELOPING THE SECOND PHASE AS WELL, AND I DO AGREE WITH COMMISSIONER FRANZ'S CONCERNS REGARDING HOURS OF DELIVERY, SO I WOULD PROPOSE THAT WE SET SOME SORT OF A LIMIT OF A START TIME EXPEND TIME AND THAT WOULD BE

[00:40:03]

ALLOWABLE.

PERHAPS SOMETHING TO MIRROR THAT COMMUNITY ADJACENT AT DEL WEBB.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: THANK YOU, VICE CHAIR.

I'M ALSO IN AGREEMENT WITH THE -- I'M SORRY -- COMMISSIONER FRANZ, AND MY QUESTION I GUESS IS TO ZACH.

DO WE, IN REGARDS TO THE TIMING AND IN PUTTING IN THIS AMENDMENT TO THE -- ARE WE SUPPOSED TO -- CAN WE LOOK AT THE WAY OTHER DEALERSHIPS OPERATE IN REGARDS TO DELIVERY OR IS IT SOMETHING WE CAN COME UP WITH OUR ON OUR OWN AND DELIVER IT ON OUR OWN?

>> ZACH HEINSELMAN: PURSUANT TO THE CODE, YOU CERTAINLY HAVE THE DISCRETION TO IMPOSE A CONDITION OF APPROVAL AS DIRECTOR SNYDER NOTED, KIND OF THE REGULATION OF HOURS OF OPERATION, METHODS OF OPERATION, SO THAT WOULD BE WITHIN YOUR DISCRETION.

I MIGHT SUGGEST MAYBE CLARIFYING THE TERM "DELIVERY" JUST TO MAKE SURE WE'RE TALKING ABOUT VEHICLE DELIVERY.

IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING OF THE DELIVERY THAT'S AT ISSUE, AND SO I HAVE BEEN SPECIFYING THOSE HOURS AND IT WOULD SEEM TO BE POTENTIALLY, IF THE COMMISSION WAS BEHIND IT, POTENTIALLY A CONDITION TO JOINT RESOLUTION 1995 REGARDING THE CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ, CAN I ASK A QUICK QUESTION? TO FOLLOW UP ON COMMISSIONER VALDEZ'S QUESTION ABOUT PEDESTRIAN ACCESS AND PARKING, IS THERE WAY TO SEE THAT AREA, TO SEE, YOU KNOW, LIKE WHAT -- HOW ARE THEY GOING TO BE ABLE TO WALK THERE IF THEY'RE GOING TO WALK TO STARBUCKS OR GET SOMETHING? CAN WE DO A VIEW OF THAT AREA? SHE IS RIGHT.

THE MORE TRAFFIC IS IN THAT AND THE MORE USE IT WILL HAVE.

IT'S INTERESTING TO SEE WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE BECAUSE I SERIOUSLY CAN'T REMEMBER WHAT THAT WHOLE CORNER LOOKS LIKE.

SO I'M ASSUMING THERE'S GOING TO BE SIDEWALKS ALONG THE FRONT OF THE PROJECT ALL THE WAY AROUND?

>> NIKKI GOMEZ: RIGHT.

FRONTING THE FIESTA KIA PROJECT.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: SO THERE'S REALLY NO EASY WAY TO CROSS OVER UNLESS YOU'RE GOING TO GO THROUGH PHASE II.

DESERT AND MAYBE THERE'S -- IS THERE A CROSSWALK ONCE YOU GET TO THAT DRIVEWAY? THERE PROBABLY ISN'T, RIGHT, GOING INTO THAT CHEVRON STATION?

>> LEILA NAMVAR: THIS IS A CROSSWALK BY NEWCASTLE DRIVE.

BASICALLY THE PHASE I THEY WILL DO IMPROVEMENT IN THE FRONTAGE, WHICH IS FIFTIES WAY AND VARNER TO THE RED LINE.

PHASE II, WHEN PHASE II COMES IN THEN THEY COMPLETE THE SIDEWALK TO THE END TO NEWCASTLE DRIVE.

IN FRONT THERE IS CROSSWALK WHEN THE LIGHT IS RED.

SO WHEN THE LIGHT IS RED, THEN PEOPLE CAN CROSS OVER.

BUT IT IS NOT -- WHEN THE LIGHT IS NOT RED, THEY CAN'T.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: THERE'S REALLY NOTHING THAT CAN BE DONE AT THIS POINT

BASED ON HOW THESE -- >> LEILA NAMVAR: COMMISSIONER FRANZ, YOU ARE MUTED.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: AM I MUTED?

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: NO, I CAN HEAR YOU.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: OKAY.

MAYBE I NEED TO RAISE MY VOLUME.

IS THAT ANY BETTER? SO IT DOESN'T LOOK LIKE THERE'S ANYWAY WE CAN IMPROVE THAT AT THIS POINT.

THERE'S NO POINT.

>> KEVIN SNYDER: COMMISSIONER FRANZ, THERE IS DIRECTOR SNYDER.

UNDER THE LEGAL RULES THAT WE OPERATE, BECAUSE THEY'RE ONLY FOCUSING ON PHASE I OR THE KIA DEALERSHIP AT THIS TIME, WE CAN ONLY LEGALLY REQUIRE THEM TO DO IMPROVEMENTS ALONG THE PORTIONS OF THE PROPERTY THEY'RE FEIGN.

WHEN THEY COME FORWARD IN THE FUTURE FOR THE PLANS FOR THE REMAINDER OF THE PROPERTY OR PHASE II, THEN AT THAT TIME THEY WOULD BE REQUIRED TO DO IMPROVEMENTS ALONG THE FRONTAGE OF VARNER ROAD THAT WOULD COMPLETE THE EFFECTS TO THE PEDESTRIAN CIRCULATION AT NEWCASTLE DRIVE THAT SENIOR PLANNER NAMVAR REFERRED TO EARLIER.

BUT LEGALLY WE CAN ONLY REQUIRE THEM TO DO THAT FOR WHICH THEY'RE SEEKING APPROVAL FOR.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: THAT MAKES SENSE.

I WAS TRYING TO VISUALIZE AND I COULDN'T VISUALIZE THAT LITTLE AREA RIGHT THERE.

SO THANK YOU.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: THERE ARE ANY OTHER COMMENTS OR RECOMMENDATIONS? I'LL GO AHEAD AND IF ANYONE WANTS TO MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE OR DOES ANYONE WANT TO MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE THE PROJECT?

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: CAN I ASK A QUICK QUESTION? WHERE, ZACH, IF THE COMMISSION IS IN AGREEMENT TO ADD HOURS OF OPERATION FOR DELIVERY OF THE VEHICLES, YOU KNOW, THE BIG -- THE BIG, YOU KNOW, TRUCKS

[00:45:06]

THAT BRING IN ALL THE VEHICLES, WHICH RESOLUTION WOULD THAT BE A PART OF.

>> ZACH HEINSELMAN: I WOULD SUGGEST THAT WOULD BE A PART OF RESOLUTION 1995, WHICH IS THE RESOLUTION PERTAINING TO THE CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR THE PROJECT.

AND IT SOUNDED LIKE THE IDEA THAT YOU WERE FLOATING AT LEAST HAD SUPPORT FROM THE OTHER COMMISSIONERS, PERHAPS MORE JUST GATHERING FROM THE COMMENTS THAT CAME IN, SO I THINK THAT IF THE COLLECTIVE COMMISSION WERE TO PROCEED DOWN THAT ROUTE, I THINK YOU WOULD WANT TO SPECIFY WHAT THOSE HOURS WOULD BE, AND THEN YOU WOULD BE MAKING A MOTION FOR 1995, PROPOSE THAT CONDITION BE ADDED.

IT SOUNDS LIKE IT WOULD BE A CONDITION TO LIMIT THE HOURS OF VEHICLE DELIVERY BETWEEN X AND X DUE TO THE PROXIMITY OF THE NEAR BY RESIDENTIAL USE.

AGAIN THAT WOULD BE 1995 IS WHERE I THINK IT WOULD FIT.

>> KEVIN SNYDER: IF I COULD ADD, I THINK IT IS IMPORTANT TO DISTINGUISH WHEN WE'RE TALKING ABOUT DELIVERY, WE'RE TALKING ABOUT DELIVERY BY SEMI TRUCKS OR OTHER LARGE VEHICLES.

IF THERE'S AN INDIVIDUAL CAR DELIVERY FROM ONE DEALERSHIP TO THE OTHER AND THEY'VE EXCHANGED VEHICLES, FOR EXAMPLE, I DON'T THINK THAT'S WHAT THE COMMISSION WAS REFERRING TO.

IT'S THE LARGE SEMI TRUCKS OR OTHER SIMILAR LARGE VEHICLES.

SO IT MIGHT BE GOOD TO REFER TO THAT IN ANY ADDED CONDITION.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: THAT MAKES PERFECT SENSE.

VICE CHAIR YSIANO, DO YOU -- WHAT IS YOUR FEELING? 7:00 A.M.

TO 6:00 P.M.? >> VICE CHAIRPERSON YSIANO: YEAH, I WOULD FEEL COMFORTABLE WITH LIKE 7:00 A.M.

TO 6:00 P.M.

OR EVEN 7:00 A.M.

TO 7:00 P.M.

SOME PEOPLE IN THAT COMMUNITY MIGHT BE EARLY SLEEPERS AND EARLY RISERS AS WELL, BUT STILL I THINK 7:00 A.M.

I KNOW MIRRORS THE COMMUNITY'S STANDARD FOR COMMERCIAL VEHICLES ON-SITE, AND I THINK 7:00 P.M.

OR 6:00 P.M.

WOULD BE AN APPROPRIATE END TIME.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: OKAY.

ALL RIGHT.

ANYBODY WANT TO TRY DOING THE MOTION?

>> VICE CHAIRPERSON YSIANO: I'LL LIKE A MOTION TO ADOPT RESOLUTION NUMBER 1994, THE PLANNING COMMISSION CITY OF INDIO TO APPROVE THE ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 20-11-553 AND TO ADOPT A MITIGATED NEGATIVE DECLARATION AND A MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM FOR THE DEVELOPMENT VARNER ROAD PROJECT INCLUDING FIESTA KIA CAR DEALERSHIP PHASE I AND TWO FAST FOOD RESTAURANTS AND RETAIL SPACES PHASE II, AND ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 20-11-553 TO BE LOCATED AT THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF VARNER ROAD AND FIFTIES WAY.

DO I NEED TO READ THE OTHER NUMBERS AT THE END THERE, ZACH?

>> ZACH HEINSELMAN: WE COULD TAKE THEM ONE BY ONE.

THAT WOULD BE APPROPRIATE.

>> VICE CHAIRPERSON YSIANO: OKAY.

APN 748-280-014 AND 748-280-015 AND 748-280-018.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: I'LL SECOND THE MOTION.

>> VICE CHAIRPERSON YSIANO: THEN I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION TO ADOPT NUMBER 1995, A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF INDIO, CALIFORNIA, CONDITIONAL I APPROVING CUP 20-11-1065 TO ALLOW A NEW CAR DEALERSHIP USE WITHIN BUSINESS PARK ZONE DISTRICT SUBJECT TO THE FINDINGS AND CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL THEREIN.

ALSO WITH THE CONDITION THAT LARGE TRUCKS AND VEHICLE DELIVERIES ARE LIMITED BETWEEN THE HOURS OF 7:00 A.M.

AND 7:00 P.M.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: I'LL SECOND.

>> VICE CHAIRPERSON YSIANO: AND FINALLY I'LL LOOK LIKE MAKE A MOTION TO ADOPT RESOLUTION NUMBER 1996, A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF INDIO CONDITIONALLY APPROVING DESIGN REVIEW 20-11-481 FOR SITE DESIGN INCLUDING SITE CIRCULATION, PARKING, BUILDING ARCHITECTURE, AND LANDSCAPING FOR A NEW CAR DEALERSHIP, FIESTA KIA, SUBJECT TO THE FINDINGS AND CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL THEREIN.

>> ZACH HEINSELMAN: COMMISSIONER YSIANO, I MIGHT ASK TO CLARIFY IF YOU ARE CONSIDERING THAT MOTION, THAT THAT WOULD BE INCLUSIVE OF THE CLARIFICATION THAT MS. GOMEZ PRESENTED AND THAT NAMVAR CIRCULATED TO CONDITION 12.

[00:50:02]

>> VICE CHAIRPERSON YSIANO: YES, IN ADDITION TO THE CONDITIONS THAT MS. GOMEZ SENT OVER EARLIER REGARDING THE ASPHALT.

CORRECT?

>> ZACH HEINSELMAN: CORRECT.

I BELIEVE IT WOULD BE CONDITION OF APPROVAL APP 12.

>> VICE CHAIRPERSON YSIANO: CORRECT.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: I'LL SECOND THE MOTION.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: ROLL CALL, PLEASE.

>> CHAIR WESTERN LOPEZ.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

CONGRATULATIONS.

AND LET'S SEE.

WE'LL GO TO THE NEXT ITEM WHICH IS AN ACTION ITEM 9.1 FISCAL YEAR 2021-22 CAPITAL

[9.1 Fiscal Year 2021-2022 Capital Improvement Program of the Indio Public Works - Finding of General Plan Consistency]

IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM OF THE INDIO PUBLIC WORKS FINDINGS OF THE GENERAL PLAN CONSISTENCY, AND BELIEVE WE HAVE ERIC WECK, PRINCIPLE CIVIL ENGINEER, WITH THE PRESENTATION.

>> YES, GOOD EVENING.

THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

I'M ERIC WECK, PRINCIPLE CIVIL ENGINEER FOR THE CITY OF INDIO PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT CAPITAL PROJECTS DIVISION.

TIM WASSIL, THE PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR AND JOSHUA NICKERSON FROM MAI CONSULTING IS ALSO AVAILABLE TO DISCUSS THE CITY'S CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS AS NEEDED.

SO TYPICALLY THIS IS THE TIME OF THE YEAR THAT THE PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT PRESENTS TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION THE CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS THAT REQUIRE FINDINGS THAT THE PROJECTS MEET GENERAL PLAN CONFORMITY.

OVER THE PAST SEVERAL MONTHS, PUBLIC WORKS STAFF HAS MET WITH CITY COUNCIL AND REVIEWED CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PRIORITIES AND ALSO IDENTIFIED NEW PROJECTS THAT HAVE NOT BEEN PRESENTED TO PRIOR PLANNING COMMISSIONS.

THERE ARE FOUR NEW PROJECTS, AND THEY'VE BEEN IDENTIFIED BY PUBLIC WORKS STAFF AND WILL BE ADDED TO THE CITY'S CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN AND ARE AS FOLLOWS: AVENUE 50 STREET WINDING BETWEEN JEFFERSON STREET AND JACKSON STREET.

COPE OF WORK ENTAILS WIDENING AVENUE 50 FROM TWO PLANES TO FOUR LANES IN EACH DIRECTION.

ROADWAY IMPROVEMENTS WILL ALSO INCLUDE SIDEWALK, CURB AND GUTTER AND DRIVEWAY APPROACHES.

AVENUE 52 ROADWAY IMPROVEMENTS WILL CONSTRUCT NEW SIDEWALKS, CURBS AND GUTTERS AND BIKE LANES LOOK THE NORTH SIDE OF AVENUE 52.

THERE WE GO.

NOW ON THIS SLIDE THERE'S TWO PROJECTS SHOWN.

THE ONE ON THE LEFT IS RANCHO LOS COYOTES, AND THOSE ROADWAY IMPROVEMENTS WILL RECONSTRUCT THE STREET BETWEEN AVENUE 38 AND AVENUE 39.

IMPROVEMENTS WILL INCLUDE THE CONSTRUCTION OF ROLLED CURBS AND DRAINAGE DRY WELLS TO MITIGATE STANDING WATER.

FINALLY, THE FOURTH NEW PROJECT THAT WE'RE ADDING IS JEFFERS STREET WIDENING BETWEEN AVENUE 38 AND AVENUE 40.

AND THAT SEEKS TO WIDEN JEFFERSON FROM TWO TO FOUR LANES WHICH WILL ALSO INCLUDE CONSTRUCTING SIDEWALKS AND BIKE LANES AS WELL.

NOW, TONIGHT PUBLIC WORKS STAFF IS HERE TO ANSWER QUESTIONS REGARDING THE CITY'S PROPOSED CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM.

INCLUDED.

IN COMMISSION'S STAFF REPORT ARE CIP SHEETS FOR ALL CURRENT PROJECTS THAT PUBLIC THE PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT IS WORKING ON.

ALL OF THESE PROJECTS ARE IN VARIOUS STAGES OF THE DEVELOPMENT, WHETHER THEY'RE IN FUNDING, ENVIRONMENTAL DESIGN OR CONSTRUCTION STAGES.

STAFF RECOMMENDS THAT RESOLUTION 1992 OR RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF INDIO, CALIFORNIA, THAT THE 2021-2022 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM OF THE CITY OF INDIO PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT IS CONSISTENT WITH THE CURRENT CITY OF INDIO GENERAL PLAN.

WE ARE NOW AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: THANK YOU, ERIC.

DOES ANY OF THE COMMISSION HAVE ANY COMMENTS FOR ERIC? OKAY.

SEEING THAT THERE ARE NONE, I WANT TO GO BACK TO ZACH.

ARE WE GOING -- DO WE NEED TO OPEN UP ANY KIND OF PUBLIC COMMENTS?

THIS IS AN ACTION ITEM, SO -- >> ZACH HEINSELMAN: THERE'S NO -- THIS IS AN ACTION ITEM.

YOU'RE CORRECT, THERE'S NO PUBLIC HEARING.

MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC WOULD HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO SUBMIT PUBLIC COMMENT ON ANY ITEM ON THE AGENDA, SO WE CAN CHECK WITH MS. BELTRAN TO SEE IF ANY REQUESTS FOR ORAL COMMENT OR ANY PREVIOUSLY SUBMITTED WRITTEN COMMENT WAS SUBMITTED, BUT

[00:55:01]

YOU'RE CORRECT, THIS IS AN ACTION ITEM.

THERE IS NO -- IT'S NOT A PUBLIC HEARING.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: MS. BELTRAN, DO WE HAVE ANY COMMENTS?

>> EVELYN BELTRAN: WE DID NOT RECEIVE ANY REQUEST FOR ORAL COMMENTS TODAY.

SO AT THIS POINT IF THE COMMISSION HAS ANY OTHER CLOSING COMMENTS.

OKAY.

IF NOT, THEN IF THERE IS -- IF WE CAN GET A MOTION TO -- ANY OF THE COMMISSIONERS LIKE TO CLOSE?

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: I'D JUST LIKE TO MAKE A COMMENT.

I THINK IT'S PHENOMENAL TO SEE ALL OF THESE IMPROVEMENTS EVEN THOUGH IT SLOWS DOWN TRAFFIC, SO I'M LOOKING FORWARD TO THEM BEING DONE.

IF THERE'S NO OTHER COMMENTS, I CAN ATTEMPT AT A MOTION.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: SO I'LL MAKE A MOTION THAT WE ADOPT RESOLUTION NUMBER 1992, A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF INDIO, CALIFORNIA, FINDING THAT THE 2021-2022 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM OF THE CITY OF PUBLIC PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT.

IS CONSISTENT WITH THE CITY OF INDIO'S GENERAL PLAN 2040.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: I'LL GO AHEAD AND SECOND THE MOTION.

>> EVELYN BELTRAN: MOTION CARRIES 4-0.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: THANK YOU, ERIC.

THERE ARE NO STUDY SESSION ITEMS. AND WE GO ON TO 11, WHICH IS STAFF ITEMS.

[11. STAFF ITEMS]

>> KEVIN SNYDER: I'LL JUST BE BRIEF.

THANK YOU ALL TO RESPONDING TO EVELYN'S INQUIRY OIS YOUR AVAILABILITY FOR THE UPCOMING JOINT STUDY SESSIONS WITH CITY COUNCIL.

AS A REMINDER ON JUNE 2ND THERE BE A STUDY SESSION ON THE HIGHWAY 111 CORRIDOR SPECIFIC PLAN FROM 3:00 TO 4:00 P.M.

IT WAS GOING TO BE 4:30 BUT WE HAD TO CUT IT BACK BECAUSE OF CLOSED SESSION ITEMS, SO 3:00 TO 4:00 P.M.

ON JUNE 2ND.

ON JUNE 16TH THERE WILL A STUDY SESSION ITEM FROM 3:30 TO 4:30 FOR THE HOUSING ELEMENT UPDATE.

THEN ON JULY 21ST THERE WILL BE ANOTHER STUDY SESSION WITH CITY COUNCIL AND THE PLANNING COMMISSION FROM 3:00 P.M.

TO 4:30 P.M., AND AGAIN THAT'S JULY 21ST.

THESE WILL BE VIRTUAL, SO IT WOULD BE SIMILAR TO THE ENVIRONMENT YOU'RE IN NOW, AND THANK YOU AGAIN FOR WORKING WITH EVELYN ON YOUR AVAILABILITY, AND IF W.

THAT I WILL TURN IT OVER TO LEILA IF SHE HAS ANY OTHER COMMENTS SHE WANTS TO MAKE.

>> LEILA NAMVAR: NO COMMENTS.

JUST I WOULD LIKE TO WELCOME COMMISSIONER VALDEZ, SO MY TEAM AND MYSELF ARE VERY EXCITED TO HAVE A FULL COMMISSION, SO WELCOME, AND WE ARE LOOKING FORWARD TO WORKING WITH YOU.

ANY QUESTIONS, YOU CAN ALWAYS DIRECT IT TO MYSELF AND DIRECTOR SNYDER ON ANY ITEMS OR ANY THINGS THAT YOU MAY NEED TO FULFILL YOUR TASK AS A COMMISSIONER.

SO WELCOME AND CONGRATULATIONS.

>> COMMISSIONER VALDEZ: THANK YOU.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: REAL QUICK QUESTION.

BACK TO KEVIN, WILL WE BE RECEIVING CALENDAR INVITES FOR THOSE TO HOLD THOSE SPECIAL MEETINGS?

>> KEVIN SNYDER: EVELYN IS SHAKING HER HEAD YES, SO YES.

THANK YOU FOR REMINDER.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

AND THEN IF THERE ARE NO OTHER STAFF ITEMS, THENELL WE GO BACK TO COMMISSIONER

[12. COMMISSIONER COMMENTS]

COMMENTS.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: I JUST WANT TO ALSO THANK COMMISSIONER VALDEZ.

THIS IS AN INTERESTING VOLUNTEER JOB THAT YOU HAVE TAKEN ON.

IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, FEEL FREE TO REACH OUT TO US.

WE'RE ALL HERE TO HELP YOU AND DON'T BE AFRAID TO ASK QUESTIONS.

WE ALL STARTED WHERE YOU ARE, AND IT WILL GET BETTER.

SO WELCOME.

>> COMMISSIONER VALDEZ? ? THANK YOU.

I APPRECIATE IT AND I'M EXCITED TO BE A PART OF THE COMMISSION AND TO HELP SEE OUR CITY GROW.

THESE PROJECTS ARE REALLY EXCITING.

AND THANK YOU.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: ANY OTHER COMMENTS?

>> KEVIN SNYDER: CHAIR, CAN I JUST SAY ONE THING ANY WANT TO THANK THE NEW COMMISSIONER AS WELL FOR GIVING UP PART OF HER SATURDAY AND ALSO THANK OUR CITY ATTORNEY.

SHE GOT HER BROWN ACT TRAINING LAST SUNDAY, AND SO IT TOOK TIME OUT OF HER WEEKEND AS WELL AS OUR CITY ATTORNEY DID, SO I WANT TO THANK YOU, COMMISSIONER, FOR BEING AVAILABLE AND ALSO THANK YOU TO THE CITY ATTORNEY FOR PROVIDING THAT TRAINING SO QUICKLY AFTER HER APPOINTMENT.

[01:00:04]

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: I'LL JUST GO AHEAD AND AGAIN CONGRATULATE AND WELCOME COMMISSIONER VALDEZ.

LOOKING FORWARD TO WORK WITH YOU, AND AGAIN YOU CAN REACH ME ANY TIME.

IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.

BUT WE ALL STARTED.

IT'S WONDERFUL TO HAVE YOU ONBOARD.

AGAIN, JUST WANT TO SAY CONGRATULATIONS AND WELCOME.

>> COMMISSIONER VALDEZ: THANK YOU GUYS.

I APPRECIATE IT.

AND PLEASE BE PATIENT WITH ME.

I WILL GET ONBOARD WITH EVERYTHING THAT'S GOING ON, BUT I'M REALLY HONORED TO BE A PART OF THE COMMISSION AND BE A PART OF MY CITY, SO THANK YOU ALL.

AND IF THERE ARE NO OTHER FURTHER COMMENTS, THEN WE'LL GO AHEAD AND I'LL ASK FOR A MOTION TO ADJOURN THE MEETING.

OUR NEXT PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING WILL BE HELD ON JUNE THE 9TH AT 6:00 P.M.

WHICH WILL BE A VIRTUAL MEETING, AND IF I CAN GET A MOTION TO ADJOURN.

>> COMMISSIONER FRANZ: I'LL MAKE THE MOTION TO ADJOURN.

>> CHAIRPERSON LOPEZ: AND I'LL SECOND.

AND IF WE CAN GET ROLL CALL, PLEASE.

>> I DON'T.